Testing resource hunger of audioplayers
This test contains the basic audio players; DeadBeeF
. It contains the mediaplayer VLC
, the very comprehensive Exaile
and the database driven music managers; pMusic
. Of course, this is not a fair compete since features differs a lot from player to player. In the end, it might be less important how much system resources the player uses. The functionality is in most cases what makes our choice. But still, it's good to know when running a low-powered system, and when choosing the default player.
From my personal view, I am interesting to see how pMusic is working compared to other players. pMusic has got a lot of criticism
of its hunger on cpu resources. I want to disprove this reputation.
My test-machine is an AsusEEE netbook 1001px (cpu:2x1.66Ghz atom).
This is a low-powered netbook that makes it easier to measure the differences in cpu-usage. Running on a modern pc, none of these players will make your system hot.
The OS is XenialPup 7.0.4.
VLC and DeadBeeF is installed by default. On this system I was able to run both Clementine and Exaile which is the most comparable to pMusic. Tried to install Amarok with no success. If you run another player of XenialPup 7.0.4
, it would be great if you gave me a link to the pet/sfs. I am interested to extend my test with more players.
The task is to play a mp3 file.
I have used the default setting for each player, and started the app at least twice to ensure no first-run operation misleads the test-result.
The compared players are:
Audacious 3.6.2, Clemetine 1.2.3, DeaDBeeF 0.7.2, Exaile 3.2.2, pMusic 5.2.4, VLC 2.2.2
playing mp3 with gui shown
Exaile 7.5 %
VLC 8.3 %
DeaDBeeF 8.8 %
Audacious 10.0 %
pMusic 12.1 %
Clementine 18.2 %
Surprisingly. I guessed DeadBeef would be the winner because of its reputation of being lightweight. Exaile is a much more comprehensive option than DeadBeeF and Audicious, and still, it has less appetite for cpu-cycles.
playing mp3 with gui shown
Audacious 5 Mb
DeaDBeeF 20 Mb
Exaile 23 Mb
VLC 25 Mb
pMusic 29 Mb
Clementine 33 Mb
Audicious is impressive. I had to verify it one more time. Let's mention that this is the Gtk gui - not the Winamp clone. Else, smaller range than expected. The guis differs from the simple (VLC) to the complex (Clementine), and I had expected the memory usage to differ more.
required for installation:
pMusic 1 Mb
Audacious 8 Mb
DeaDBeeF 10 Mb
VLC 53 Mb
Clementine 66 Mb
Exaile 66 Mb
pMusic is built for Puppy, and take advantage of already existing dependencies. That makes it of course the smallest, but it is also the only player that is not compiled, and that is probably another reason for the result.
Clementine is overall the heavy choice. I hoped to compare with Amarok which I assume it is the biggest brother (153 Mb install), but I were not able to get it work in Xenial. Hopefully, someone make a pack some day, and I will update these results.